Author Archive

Relevance and Motivation

Posted July 16, 2007 By Dave Thomer

I was all set to link to an essay in the Times of London about education tat is pretty darn close to the exact opposite of my thinking in terms of the role of the teacher. And then when I went to reread the essay and get the URL I discovered that the Times site is down for maintenance. After an hour of trying to come up with something else to write, I’m saying to heck with it, going from memory, and promising to update this post with the link later.

The basic idea was that the essayist was bemoaning the effort to make school subjects relevant to students’ lives and interests, because a teacher’s responsibility is not to the students, it is to the knowledge that the teacher passes on. The teacher presents the knowledge, finds that small group of students who are willing to accept it on the terms that the teacher offers, and leaves the rest to their fates.

I don’t even know where to begin, but I’ll start with this: if no one cares about the knowledge, then the knowledge dies. When people care about the knowledge, it multiplies. (If you doubt me, go check out how much space Wikipedia has devoted to the exploits of fictional characters.)

I’d move on to a more general point that students who see a way to use knowledge will generally do a better job of absorbing, retaining, and understanding that knowledge; indeed, for many theorists, the ability to use information is one of the defining elements of comprehension. But I’ve been blabbing about Dewey for a while here, so you probably already have that idea.

Point so far is, even if a teacher’s job is knowledge propagation, it sure seems to be that a teacher would be interested in maximizing his or her chances of success. The alternative seems to be the equivalent of throwing a bunch of seeds into uncultivated land and claiming that the farmer’s responsibility is only to those seeds who happen to find a spot where they can grow.

Beyond that, though, is that I have a completely different conception of the role of a teacher, especially at the pre-college level. Teachers are driving many of the formative experiences of the next generation of society, so it kind of behooves everyone to make those experiences constructive ones. I know there are realities to deal with and compromises to be made, but geez, can we at least get a decent read on the ideal?

Thoughts on Ratatouille

Posted July 15, 2007 By Dave Thomer

We went to see the new Pixar movie Ratatouille today. It was quite good, although the pacing was unconventional. As a result, I think there’s a little more distance between this film and me in comparison with Brad Bird’s left effort for Pixar, The Incredibles. The movie centers around Remy, a rat whose senses are so acute that he develops a fondness for excellent food and a desire to create it himself. His father and his fellow rats are less interested in gourmet ideals, but when Remy gets separated from his colony and finds himself in Paris, he lurks around the kitchen at the restaurant founded by his idol, Gusteau. Gusteau has been dead for years, of a heart attack brought on in part by a harsh review, and the restaurant has been trading on its former glory. Remy winds up forming an unlikely partnership with Linguini, a hapless lad who just wants a job as a garbage boy – and who happens to be Gusteau’s son and heir.

Spoilers follow.

What surprised me was that the movie resolves the Gusteau’s will plotline with a good 40 minutes or so left in the movie. I expected that the “rightful heir discovers his identity and claims his birthright� plot to figure into the climax, as it does in so many Disney movies. But instead, that just turns into the catalyst for the final act, where Remy and Linguini have to confront a chef’s arch-nemesis, the food critic, while they resolve their own interpersonal conflicts. It’s an interesting dynamic, and I’m still trying to figure out how well all the threads come together. The ending also pulls the rug out from the heroes right at their moment of triumph, but lets them land on their feet. It’s an example of Bird’s effort to inject a certain amount of realism into his fantastic premise, although I find myself overthinking the ramifications of a world where it becomes clear that rats are capable of higher-level thinking and communication. I probably shouldn’t hold that against the movie, though.

Technically, the movie lives up to the Pixar standards – the rats all have individual character, Remy is extremely expressive, and the many chase sequences are involving but never distracting. The voice cast does a great job, with many of the actors using accents that made them unrecognizable to me. All in all, it’s a fine piece of work.

Shopping Discoveries

Posted July 14, 2007 By Dave Thomer

Couple of points learned during today’s errand-running:

1. Clothespins are much harder to find than I thought they would be. I’ve looked in department stores, drug stores, and a Bed Bath and Beyond, and no luck. From the Amazon searches I did when I got home tonight, it looks like hardware stores might be my best bet. So off to the store tomorrow, it seems. I mean, if the sun’s gonna be beating down anyway, may as well put some of that energy to work. Doing more than the whole sustaining life as we know it thing, anyway.

2. I’m looking for beverages that don’t have high fructose corn syrup, and boy howdee that ain’t easy either. But Whole Foods does stock single serving bottles of several varieties of Kristall fruit sodas. I wasn’t crazy about their Orange, but the Lemon Lime Twist was quite refreshing. Nantucket Nectars look like a good option, too.

Lots in a Name

Posted July 13, 2007 By Dave Thomer

Started up another batch of education classes this week. Reflecting on the week, most of what I learned appears to be technical terminology for things that are pretty obvious with a few minutes’ thought. Indeed, many of the ideas I’ve encountered are things that have been in the back of my head for a while, and I can see them manifested in some of the exercises I use. But the weird thing is that, somehow, pulling these tidbits into a systematized body of knowledge, jargon and all, has helped me bring some things into focus a little more clearly. In and of itself that might be a useful discovery for down the road, but I don’t want to get carried away. One of my textbooks refers to hypothetico-deductive reasoning, and I think I might hurt myself trying to say that.

Games I Am Not Playing

Posted July 12, 2007 By Dave Thomer

Not counting my PC, I haven’t owned a video game machine since my brothers and I shared a Super Nintendo back in the proverbial day. I must admit that the upcoming Star Wars game The Force Unleashed and BioWare’s forthcoming Mass Effect have me seriously reconsidering that, as soon as the change under my sofa accumulates a heck of a lot more. There’s fodder for a rumination on video games as a new narrative medium here, but other people have covered that ground and I don’t know if I have the mental juice for it at the moment.

Then again, there are always placed like the 1984 Arcade, a place from which Earl has just returned. Check out pictoral evidence of the pilgrimage over at Scribblings.

Getting Practice In

Posted July 11, 2007 By Dave Thomer

I’ve finally resumed the process of putting old articles from the site’s prior format into the blog database. Tonight, Life in Practice essays from 2000-2004 can now be found from that helpful link in the sidebar.

My to do list says I’m supposed to tackle the Special Order Speeches section tomorrow, but that’s seeming ambitious.

I don’t know how much longer the old phpBB forum will be around on the site. I’m going to pull all old essays and reviews into WordPress, if my fingers don’t fall off. If anyone has a particular discussion thread and/or response they want to preserve, let me know and I’ll find a way to wrangle ’em.

Time on Earth: First Impressions

Posted July 10, 2007 By Dave Thomer

Don’t know if I’m gonna write a full review or not, but here’s what I’m thinking after three passes through the new album:

  • If Wikipedia is correct about which four songs the full lineup worked on with Steve Lillywhite as producer, I think it makes sense to view Time on Earth as a Neil Finn solo record with a Crowded House EP attached. There’s a fairly substantial shift in tone and style on the full lineup songs: Don’t Stop Now, She Called Up, Even a Child, and Transit Lounge. They’re four of the fastest songs on the record, and they have a certain playfulness that’s not nearly as prominent on the other songs. The backing vocals on She Called Up and Transit Lounge in particular provoked a double-take.
  • The other tracks were produced by Ethan Johns, who also produced Glen Phillips’ solo album Abulum. There’s a similar quiet, melancholy vibe on those two albums, and it’s not unpleasant to listen to by any means.
  • Even a Child, co-written by Johnny Marr, is a fantastic, high-energy pop song and if I had paid 11 bucks just for that track, I’d call it money well spent. If that Modest Mouse thing doesn’t work out, I think I’d like to see Marr collaborate with this band some more. Didn’t think I was gonna say that before I heard the album, but he fit in really well with the whole crew.
  • I really, really hope the full band heads back into the studio as soon as possible. I don’t know if this lineup can top Together Alone, but I don’t put it past them.

Textbooks. Joy.

Posted July 9, 2007 By Dave Thomer

Had an 8:40 AM education class today. I didn’t handle 8:40 AM classes well when I had no kids, was single, and lived five minutes from the classroom building. Throw in the wife, kids, and 75-minute commute, and hoo-boy, have I been a zombie today.

Did some textbook orders for my fall classes – thank goodness for databases that let you do searches by ISBN code. I didn’t realize that we’re apparently shifting to longer 13-digit ISBN codes, but there is unsurprisingly a copious amount of ISBN information on Wikipedia.

I’m also looking for textbooks on economics and various topics in world history for my own use. I may have found some candidates – I’ll report back – but if anyone wants to toss suggestions into the comments, go for it.

Tarp Karma, Here We Come

Posted July 8, 2007 By Dave Thomer

Nothing profound today, but I must say I got a kick out of this story: not only did the Phillies avoid losing the 10,000th game in their history – they’ll be the first pro sports franchise ever to lose that many, once it happens – they helped save the Colorado grounds crew from a runaway tarp during a rain delay. Now we just need to ride that tarp onto a hot streak.

Live, from Earth, Take Two

Posted July 7, 2007 By Dave Thomer

I had this whole post going about Live Earth, and then I deleted it before I could save it. So go check out this AP article to see Neil Finn paraphrased about the need for musicians to factor carbon offsets into their touring plans, and check out this interview with Al Gore where he discusses Live Earth as the beginnings of a major PR campaign.

For my part, I’m waiting for MSN’s live stream of the Sydney show to get around to showing Crowded House’s set again, in hopes of catching the encore I missed when I watched it the first time. (The sun was up in Philly by the time they played “Weather with You,” and I needed to get to bed.) I also got the laundry rack out of storage and I’m gonna see if I can make a go of drying the laundry without using the dryer. Every little bit, right?